null

Beyond the Hype: Dailies Total 1 vs. Acuvue Oasys Compared

24th Feb 2025

lenses-online-dailies-total-1-vs-acuvue-oasys-1-day-contact-lenses-hero-image.png

When it comes to daily disposable contact lenses - Alcon’s Dailies Total 1 and J&J Acuvue Oasys Dailies have earned their reputation for quality and performance, particularly among users with dry eyes or astigmatism.

Let’s break down what makes each of these lenses unique and see how they compare in comfort, cost, and UV protection.

Below is a quick reference table outlining the key specifications of both daily lenses:

 lenses-online-dailies-total-1-vs-acuvue-oasys-1-day-contact-lenses.png

Note: Oxygen permeability is an important indicator of eye health. Dailies Total 1’s higher dk/t may appeal to users concerned about oxygen flow to the cornea, while Acuvue Oasys’ UV protection can be a deciding factor for outdoor enthusiasts.

Comfort and Wearability

Daily disposable lenses, in general, are designed for ease of use—a key reason why many new wearers prefer them. Surveys show that about 82% of new daily disposable wearers report ease of insertion, while 72% find them easy to remove, underscoring the overall user-friendly nature of this lens category.

Users with particularly dry eyes often lean towards Dailies Total 1, as its Water Gradient and SmarTears technology create a moisture-rich surface that feels almost “invisible” on the eye. 

Conversely, Acuvue Oasys Dailies use HydraLuxe technology, designed to mimic natural tears and maintain comfort over long periods.

Since individual experiences can vary, with some users citing differences in insertion or removal consulting your local optometrist is still highly recommended.

Cost Considerations

Generally, Dailies Total 1 tends to be more cost-effective, while Acuvue Oasys Dailies might come at a slight premium due to their additional UV protection. For those transitioning from bi-weekly or monthly lenses, the convenience and reduced maintenance of dailies can outweigh the marginal price difference.

UV Protection

Acuvue Oasys Dailies offer Class 1 UV blocking, an attractive feature for those who spend significant time outdoors. You might find this important if you live in sunny climates or engage in outdoor activities. 

Dailies Total 1 do not emphasise UV protection, so if safeguarding your eyes against the sun is a priority, this might influence your choice.

What our customers say

Dailies Total1 is highly valued for its exceptional comfort and often highlighted for its excellent moisture retention. However, the high water content that enhances comfort can also make the lenses trickier to remove, with some users needing to adopt alternative removal techniques:

"Excellent Lenses and extremely comfortable. Excellent packaging of individual Lens and appears to prevent Lens flipping inside out during transport/storage. BUT very hard to remove, as the 100% water on the surface means the normal method that I have pinch removed lenses with thumb and middle finger (used this for 40 years and a variety of Lenses), does not work at all. Tried various tweezers/suction cups/pincers that you can buy on-line, but the only thing that works is a sterile disposable latex glove that gives a grip on the lens. I have actually cut the thumb/middle finger from the glove and just slip that on for removal. A real hassle, but worth it for the fit and comfort of the lens." - Chris 

“Great lenses. Recently moved to these and they are so much more comfortable and my eyes are keeping in better health. Optometrist highlighted this higher water content and softer lenses were pretty essential if I want to keep wearing contacts daily for many years to come." - Jane D 

"The first time I have bought this brand & I’m so glad I did. They are the easiest lenses to put in and by far the most comfortable. You barely notice that you are wearing contact lenses. Thrilled!!" - Michael B

"Ordered for my friend to try instead of her original ones. Now she is hooked, much prefers the dailies total due to the comfort and softness" - Jo G

"This product is amazing for those of us who suffer from dry eyes. It is comfortable beyond belief and my eyes don't get dry at all. No more lubricating eye drops for me. It is also nice to have a clean pair every day." - Michelle P.

Users consistently praise both the standard and astigmatism-correcting versions of Acuvue Oasys Hydraluxe One Day for their comfort and convenience. They find the lenses easy to wear throughout the day, with some noting improved ease during activities like horseback riding. 

Astigmatism sufferers highlight excellent vision correction and a hassle-free experience. Across both types, reviewers appreciate the reliable performance, value for money, and simplicity—often comparing them to wearing no contacts at all.

"work well - make life easier when riding horses" - Tim S

"Awesome product very easy to wear and eyes were comfy all day". - Taunya K

"I have used these regularly and the astigmatism correction is amazing" - Chris C

"Next best thing to wearing no contacts" - Joanne L

These diverse experiences underline that while technical specifications are important, personal comfort ultimately varies from one wearer to another.

Final Thoughts and Recommendations

Both Dailies Total 1 and Acuvue Oasys Dailies represent excellent choices for daily disposable contact lenses, each with its own set of strengths:

Choose Dailies Total 1 if you’re looking for a cost-effective solution with superior moisture technology that excels in comfort for dry eyes.

Opt for Acuvue Oasys Dailies if UV protection and sustained clarity during extended outdoor activities are key to your lifestyle.

No matter your choice, it’s important to consult with your optometrist. They can provide a personalised trial to ensure the lenses meet your specific needs like if you’re managing conditions like astigmatism or chronic dryness.

Other product comparisons you might be interested in:

References: